“Studies have shown that lower
pitched voices are perceived as more competent.” This was a primary topic of
discussion on NPR’s recent segment entitled “Talking While Female.” For purely
biological reasons, women are disadvantaged when it comes to their ability to
command authority simply because their voice boxes are smaller than men’s. Partly,
according to Rindy Anderson, professor of biology at Florida Atlantic University,
this is a function of women generally being shorter and less hormonal than the
opposite sex. This poses a problem for intellectual women the world over who
fail to garner the respect they deserve from their contemporaries and from men
in power who naturally have lower voices. It is no great mystery that men are often
placed in positions of power more easily than women, and while, no doubt, the
complexity of this issue goes well beyond the parameters simply of vocal pitch,
the reality of the differences that exist in vocal tones among men and women
may be a considerable factor of why this discrepancy exists. In the realm of women
in politics, studies have shown that, when compared side by side, political ads
done by women who speak in lower tones are more successful than ads done by
women who speak in higher, more cheery tones. This evidence has even led women
to purposefully speak lower and more “masculine” in such situations in order to
gain support for their campaigns. Consequently, in an attempt to sound more
competent, many women feel forced to speak in their lowest register, a
phenomenon known as “vocal fry,” which studies have shown both men and women
consider untrustworthy tonally. Not to mention, it is very difficult and in
fact damaging to the vocal chords for a woman to maintain speaking in her
lowest register at all times and in all situations. What can we do to resolve
this dilemma? For one, I personally believe that we as a society should start
focusing more on the ideals and values of women and ignore how their
speaking voices sound; whether a woman’s voice is perceived as “competent” or “incompetent”
is in the end truthfully irrelevant if they have good ideals. Whether we like
it or not, the voices we were born with are the voices we have to offer to the
world, and we should be proud of the way we sound and feel free to express
ourselves openly without criticisms or judgment.
https://bitchmedia.org/post/women-are-making-headway-in-the-male-dominated-world-of-podcasts
No comments:
Post a Comment